Trump Threatens International Students in New Executive Order

Amongst the barrage of executive orders sent out by Trump’s team- 65 so far, in about 6 weeks of his presidency- an executive order threatening freedom of speech for international students leaves student activists afraid to raise their voices. Trump’s executive order 14188, or “Additional Measures to Combat Anti-Semitism”, aims to curb campus anti-semitism in the wake of protests against Israel’s war on Gaza and illegal occupation of Palestine. The issue, of course, is that these measures define any criticism of the Israeli government as anti-Semitic- and liken any support of Palestinian resistance as supporting terrorism. This bill is dangerous for everyone- because it polices free speech and encourages government surveillance on college campuses.  It is especially dangerous for students in the United States on a student visa- a demographic that often pays more than their national counterparts- and contributes largely to local economies near their schools. Threatening to report “anti-Semitic” behavior to local and federal law enforcement- and alluding to deporting students who do participate in demonstrations, protests, or even associate with those who do, is a dangerous precedent to set, and is harmful to accruing international talent from across the world.

Protests for Palestine are not the first time that college protesters have been arrested, detained, or put on a list for engaging in a demonstration against U.S. interests. In Ohio, Kent State University students were shot and killed by the Ohio National Guard for protesting against the U.S invasion of Cambodia in 1970. The University itself laid a memorial for the students years later and acknowledged that the Guards over-reached in their reaction to the unarmed students. The site of the massacre is considered a National Historic Landmark. In 1991, US students across the country protested against the United States’ involvement in conflicts in the Middle East. Protests were described as peaceful, yet students at UC Santa Cruz were arrested for civil disobedience. Students engaging with protests of U.S. interference in the Middle East are now known to have been put on lists- including on the no-fly list or targetted for federal and state surveillance. These protests are now known to be hallmarks of the American values of democracy, with many students who participated in these protests being celebrated for being on the right side of history. In contrast, surveillance lists that targeted students have ensured incredibly shameful results, such as being plainly inaccurate in their assessments of students as having sympathies that align with ‘terrorist sympathizer” . They are also the basis for lawsuits- including by entities like CAIR and the ACLU- who view the surveillance as a violation of free speech and discriminatory in their target.

Today, thousands of students in schools across the country are asking that their universities divest from supporting the genocide in Gaza. They are protesting the occupation of Palestine, and the war crimes currently being perpetrated by Israel. These protests, though they are reported as disorganized, violent, and anti-Semitic, have clear demands, and are largely peaceful. Students are demanding that universities withdraw investments from companies that support the Israeli occupation, such as weapons manufacturers who sell weapons to the state or technology and software companies that allow Israel to spy on Palestinians. The students also demand that all endowments given to the universities be disclosed, that the money be traceable, and that this information be available to anyone who would like to access it.

Trump’s executive order also threatens student safety with many non-law enforcement agencies aiming to report cases of “anti-Semitism” by harming students associated with critiquing the Israeli government. Student Justice for Palestine, one of the groups that is associated with protests against the Israeli government,  insists that the protestors, student activists, and Palestinians on campus be protected from doxxing, threats, and physical violence. Zionist organizations on campus like Canary Mission, Chabad, and Trojans for Israel  post images, names, addresses, social media handles, and even the addresses of family members of student organizers. Doxxing is a form of harassment and a threat of violence for students and their families. 

Universities, in the past several months, have allowed trucks displaying the names and addresses of student activists to drive around campus. Some of the students who were victims of doxxing had not even organized for an anti-zionist cause- they were simply of Palestinian background and were subject to threatening behavior on this grounds.

Trump’s executive order on anti-Semitism violates free speech, and will make it more unfavorable for international students to study in the United States, contribute to research development and the economy. Painting those who protest Israel’s policies as anti-Semitic, and censoring any criticism of a foreign government using U.S. law is a dangerous precedent to freedom of speech, and Trump’s own America First policies. Many students involved in the protests argue only that Israel is not above international law or  moral questioning.  This genocide and the political response across the world have made it clear that Israel’s actions must be reevaluated. To liken students’ voicing of  political beliefs as hate speech, and allowing the government to surveil or even deport them for those beliefs is wholly un-American- as well as an unproductive approach to differing views about global politics.