Addressing Equity and Access for Housing
A comprehensive literature survey examining systemic barriers to housing equity, the legacy of redlining, mortgage lending disparities, and the criminalization of homelessness.
Housing has been a sensitive topic and issue in the United States because it rides on systematic inequalities. Non-white populations, particularly Black, Hispanic, and Indigenous groups, face disproportionate challenges in accessing affordable and stable housing. This literature survey synthesizes recent academic research to critically examine the factors driving these inequities, the impact of these disparities, and the effectiveness of policies designed to address them.
Systemic Barriers to Housing Equity
Systemic barriers to housing equity are grounded on historical and contemporary policies, practices, and social structures that disproportionately disadvantage non-white populations in the United States (Reece, 2021). These barriers manifest through multiple interrelated mechanisms, including discriminatory practices, structural inequalities, and unequal access to resources.
Historical Context and Redlining
Redlining serves as a notable example of systemic racism in housing and its lasting impact on non-white populations in the United States (Flournoy, 2021; Linde et al., 2023). Grounded on the color-coded maps created by the Home Owners' Loan Corporation (HOLC) in the 1930s, redlining systematically classified neighborhoods with significant Black and minority populations as "hazardous" for investment (Fishback et al., 2023).
HOLC maps used red shading to mark neighborhoods considered high-risk, predominantly due to their racial composition rather than actual financial risks (Greene, 2021). Predominantly Black neighborhoods in cities like Chicago, Detroit, and Philadelphia were consistently downgraded regardless of the socioeconomic status or the stability of their residents (Markley, 2023).
The HOLC maps denied minority communities access to homeownership and led to economic disinvestment. While the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) insured millions of loans for white families, Black families were systematically excluded, forcing many into substandard rental housing (Scherer, 2023). Redlined neighborhoods saw significant disinvestment from banks, businesses, and local governments, resulting in deteriorating infrastructure, underfunded schools, and limited access to essential services (Powell, 2021).
Residential Segregation and Zoning Laws
Residential segregation in the United States is perpetrated in contemporary American society through zoning laws under the guise of "neutral" urban planning (Adams-Schoen, 2022). These laws have had far-reaching consequences for non-white populations, limiting their access to affordable housing, quality education, and economic opportunities.
Exclusionary zoning policies required large minimum lot sizes, single-family zoning, and costly building requirements that effectively excluded low-income and minority residents (Goetz, 2021). Predominantly Black neighborhoods were often zoned for industrial use, leading to higher exposure to pollution and environmental hazards, while white neighborhoods were reserved for residential use with better infrastructure and amenities (Cole et al., 2021).
Consequences of Zoning Laws
The legacy of exclusionary zoning has perpetuated racial disparities in housing, wealth, and access to opportunities. Key consequences include:
- Restricted access to high-opportunity areas with better schools and job opportunities
- Disparities in public services funded by property taxes
- Environmental inequities from industrial zoning in minority neighborhoods
- Economic inequality and widening wealth gaps
- Barriers to affordable housing development through NIMBY opposition
Disparities in Mortgage Lending
Disparities in mortgage lending are a persistent barrier to equitable housing access and wealth accumulation for non-white populations. Kim (2024) highlighted that these disparities are rooted in historical practices and perpetuated by modern lending systems which disproportionately affect Black, Hispanic, and Indigenous borrowers.
Black and Hispanic borrowers are significantly more likely to be denied mortgage loans compared to white borrowers, even when controlling for income, credit score, and other factors. Data from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau showed that in 2021, Black applicants were denied loans at a rate more than twice that of white applicants (18% vs. 8%) (Showers, 2023).
Even when non-white borrowers are approved for loans, they are often offered higher interest rates and less favorable terms. Black and Hispanic borrowers pay an average of 3.6% higher interest rates than white borrowers on comparable loans (Tarbhai & Pollack, 2022), translating to thousands of dollars in additional costs over the life of a mortgage.
Criminalization of Homelessness
Homelessness is criminalized in the United States and disproportionately affects non-white individuals who are overrepresented in the homeless population (Richard, 2023). Criminalizing homelessness involves punitive measures that perpetuate systemic inequities and compound barriers to stable housing (Rankin, 2021).
Contemporary forms of criminalization include anti-camping laws, panhandling bans, loitering and trespassing laws, and sweeps of homeless encampments. Cities like Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Austin have increased enforcement of anti-camping ordinances, leading to displacement of homeless encampments into more dangerous and isolated areas (Herring, 2020).
The consequences of criminalizing homelessness include barriers to housing (criminal records disqualify applicants), economic hardship from fines and court fees, health and safety risks from sweeps and displacement, and erosion of civil rights (Aykanian & Fogel, 2019; Allen, 2021; Barocas et al., 2023).
Recommendations for Reform
Addressing housing inequity requires bold, systemic reforms:
- Eliminating single-family zoning to increase affordable housing options (Bettencourt & Talen, 2022)
- Implementing inclusionary zoning policies requiring affordable units in new developments (Anacker, 2020)
- Decoupling school funding from local property taxes to reduce disparities (Garnett, 2023)
- Promoting regional planning to prevent exclusionary zoning in suburbs (Schuetz, 2020)
- Reforming credit scoring models to reduce bias against non-white borrowers
References
Adams-Schoen, S. J. (2022). The White Supremacist Structure of American Zoning Law. Brook. L. Rev., 88, 1225.
Allen, S. (2021). The Role of the Excessive Fines Clause in Ending the Criminalization of Homelessness. Colum. JL & Soc. Probs., 55, 499.
Anacker, K. B. (2020). Inclusionary zoning and inclusionary housing in the United States. In Research handbook on community development (pp. 189-203). Edward Elgar Publishing.
Aykanian, A., & Fogel, S. J. (2019). The Criminalization of Homelessness. Homelessness Prevention and Intervention in Social Work, 185-205.
Bettencourt, L., & Talen, E. (2022). Beyond the Single-Family Home: Zoning, Equity, and Access. The Kreisman Initiative on Housing Law and Policy Symposium.
Cole, H. V., et al. (2021). Adapting the environmental risk transition theory for urban health inequities. Social Science & Medicine, 277, 113907.
Fishback, P. V., et al. (2023). The HOLC maps: How race and poverty influenced real estate professionals' evaluation of lending risk. The Journal of Economic History, 83(4), 1019-1056.
Flournoy, E. B. (2021). The rising of systemic racism and redlining in the United States. Journal of Sustainable Social Change, 13(1), 6.
Garnett, N. S. (2023). Decoupling property and education. Columbia Law Review, 123(5), 1367-1410.
Goetz, E. G. (2021). Democracy, exclusion, and white supremacy: How should we think about exclusionary zoning?. Urban Affairs Review, 57(1), 269-283.
Herring, C. (2020). Cruel Streets: Criminalizing Homelessness in San Francisco. University of California, Berkeley.
Kim, I. (2024). Dreaming for unveiling housing inequality: mortgage lending disparities within the heartland of America. SN Business & Economics, 4(10), 122.
Markley, S. N. (2023). Planning spatial obsolescence: Racial capitalism, the homeowners' loan corporation, and the production of racialized devaluation. University of Georgia.
Powell, R. (2021). Redlining, neighborhood decline, and violence. City University of New York.
Rankin, S. K. (2021). Civilly criminalizing homelessness. Harv. CR-CLL Rev., 56, 367.
Reece, J. (2021). Confronting the legacy of "separate but equal". RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal, 7(1), 110-133.
Richard, M. K. (2023). Race matters in addressing homelessness. American Journal of Community Psychology, 72(3-4), 464-485.
Scherer, A. (2023). The Impact of Policy: How Federal Housing Policy Shapes Citizenship. Ohio University.
Schuetz, J. (2020). To improve housing affordability, we need better alignment of zoning, taxes, and subsidies. Brookings Institution.
Showers, C. (2023). Erasing racial harms in CFPB v. Community Financial Services Association. Minn. L. Rev. Headnotes, 108, 157.
Tarbhai, U., & Pollack, E. (2024). Racial disparities in student loan affordability. Jobs for the Future.
Join the Fight for Housing Justice
Together, we can dismantle the systems that perpetuate housing inequality and build a more just society for all.
